
The Gist: Happy Monday afternoon everyone! This is the first week of our discussion of
Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran Foer, and I hope you're as excited as I am. I have been dying to read this book for some time now, and I'm glad that I'm reading it with you guys. I've read one of his novels so far,
Everything Is Illuminated, and I absolutely loved it! And I really like what I've read of
Eating Animals thus far. So let's begin!
I asked you to read the first three sections of the book for our discussion today. The first is entitled "Storytelling," in which Foer talks about his background, specifically his relationship with his Grandmother, and how her life revolved around food. She was a surviver of World War II by staying on the run, and she ate to stay alive, in comparison to how most Americans live, in which we eat whatever we please, even if we're not hungry. Foer also talks about how he came to the understanding of how the eating of meat meant that you were eating animals, and that once he came to this realization, he has gone back and forth between eating meat and being a vegetarian. He shares that he felt the need to write the book once he himself became a father. He truly wanted to learn what meat actually is.
The second section is called "All or Nothing or Something Else." He begins the section by talking about his beloved family dog, George, who is actually a female. Before George, Foer was not a dog person, but he explains that once he saw George, he fell in love. He goes on to talk about how his relationship with George has led him to question the difference between animals and humans. It also leads him to question why we eat certain animals, and not others, which is different in each culture. As we know, animals that we would not eat in US—primarily dogs and cats—are eaten in other parts of the world, and Foer wants to know why. He then brings up our relationship to fish and factory farmed animals, which he describes as full out war. We have used technology to increase our production of our meat to a tremendous extent, and even though people don't know everything about these industries, they know enough, and they still don't change their habits. Foer questions why this is.
In the third section, "Words/Meaning," Foer lists words relating to the eating of animals, and gives a definition of some kind, whether it's an actual definition, or a story behind the word for phrase. Some examples include "Animal," "Battery Cage," "Comfort Food," "PETA," and "Radical."
The Discussion: Here are two discussion points to help get the conversation started. I look forward to hearing from you!
1. Foer brings up stories of his Grandmother's relationship with food at the beginning of the book, which come from his memories, as well as his family traditions. How much do you think tradition and culture affects the way we eat? By being a vegetarian or vegan, do you feel like you've gone against your family tradition, or do you still find a way to keep it alive?
2. Foer says that it was the birth of his son which pushed him to write this book. Has an experience in your life ever caused you to make a big change or to accomplish something you've never done before?
The Assignment:
Please read the next two sections of Eating Animals for our discussion on February 7. If you still need a copy, you can purchase one at the VN Store.
~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig