The Gist: Hello VegNews Book Clubbers! It's time to discuss chapters 17 to 25 of The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. This section is mainly focused on Jurgis alone, and a number of changes take place for him. It starts off with Jurgis still in jail, where he has to remain for 30 days. Once out, he makes his way back to the house, but finds it occupied by a completely different family. He soon finds out where his family is staying—in the boarding house in which they previously stayed—and goes there, only to find out that Ona is having a premature birth of their second child. Ona is in horrible pain, and the family cannot afford a doctor to attend to her. So Jurgis sets out to beg for help and comes back with a Dutch midwife. Unfortunately, it is too late and after several hours the midwife reports that the baby is dead, and that Ona will die shortly due to blood loss. Jurgis goes up to see her one last time, and observes her death, which causes him a terrible amount of grief, so he leaves to get drunk. His mother-in-law helps him to realize that he still has a son, and Jurgis gets it back together and goes to find a job, but Packingtown is not an option because he has been black listed. He finally finds a job, only to lose it a few days later due to the factory being shut down. He is then given another job that is very far from the boarding house, so he only travels home on the weekends. One such weekend he comes home to find out that his only son has drowned in the mud on the street.

Jurgis totally loses it at this point, and he deserts the rest of the family and leaves the city. He spends the summer living as a tramp in the countryside, working odd jobs here and there. When the winter rolls around once again, he ventures back into the city to find a job. He finds one digging underground tunnels for railroad, but gets injured on the job. After spending two weeks in the hospital he is kicked out and finds out that he has lost his job. He has no other option but to beg for his life, and one night he comes across a drunk, wealthy young man, who takes him to his mansion and gives Jurgis a hundred dollar bill without even thinking about it. Unfortunately, Jurgis tries to get change from the bill, but is tricked by a bartender who takes his money. Infuriated, Jurgis attacks the man, but is stopped by the police, and is sent back to jail. While in prison, he meets a man who he previously met in jail, Jack Duane, who lives a life of crime. Jurgis follows Jack's path, getting involved with politics, which are completely corrupt at the time. He gets sent back to Packingtown to become a hog trimmer, and to show support for a Republican candidate in order to receive political graft.

The Discussion: Whew! Like I said, much takes place in these chapters, as you see from my long summary above. Here are a couple of discussion questions to start the conversation. I look forward to hearing your thoughts!

1. As mentioned before, this book is primarily an attack on capitalism. What are your thoughts and feelings on capitalism? Do you think the system helps the factory farming industry grow? If the socioeconomic system changed, do you think it would benefit the animal rights movement?

2. What are your feelings on Jurgis's character? Do you think he's making the right decisions? Does he have any choice, in your opinion?

The Assignment: Please read chapters 26 to the end of The Jungle for our discussion on Monday, September 28.

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig

The Summary: Happy Friday! I hope everyone had an enjoyable week. Discussion was light this week, and I want to thank Hope-g for participating. We talked about the connection between humans and animals portrayed in The Jungle, and how the characters are treated like animals, in which their voice is not heard, and how they are used and then thrown out by the Packingtown system—much like how animals are used and then slaughtered. We also discussed the human rights issues within the factory farming industry. Without some solution to the horrible abuses on the human level, the animals will never be truly helped. It's important to look at the problem as a whole in order to make change.

We will discuss chapters 17 to 25 next week. Have a great weekend!

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig

The Gist: Good afternoon everyone! I am just returning from Toronto, and gearing up to discuss chapters 6 to 16 of The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. Much has occurred in the lives of the main characters of the book, specifically Jurgis, Ona, Teta Elzbieta, Marija, Stanislovas, and the other children of the family—all of it negative. They have been used and abused by the Packingtown system, and by the end of chapter 16, they are literally in despair. Ona has been taken advantage of by her boss, and Jurgis is now in jail for seeking revenge for his family by attacking the man with the intent to kill him. This week's reading has mainly focused on humans, but there is a connection between how these characters are treated and animals. Neither the humans nor the non-humans can be heard or express their rights.

The Discussion: This book is chock-full of discussion points, but I would like to keep it to two, so that we can maintain a focus. I look forward to reading your comments!

1. Above, I mentioned the symbolism and connection between the humans and animals in the book. Do you agree with this conclusion? Can you point out some parts of the reading where this is apparent? Do you think that Sinclair knew that he was making this connection?

2. This book is very sad, almost to the point of hopelessness. Although this book is set in 1906, there are still problems like this today, in which the people who work on factory farms are horribly abused. As vegans and animal-rights activists, we can sometimes forget about the human-rights abuses of this industry. What could we do to help change these problems? Do you think that if we worked to change these problems that it could help the animals as well?

The Assignment: Please read chapters 17 to 25 for our discussion on Monday, September 15.

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig

The Summary: Good morning everyone! I am currently reporting from Canada, where I am working the Toronto Vegetarian Food Fair. The show starts at 4 pm today, so if you're in the area, please stop by!

This first week's discussion went really well, and I appreciate those who left comments. I first asked if you think that more teenagers would go veg if The Jungle were required reading in school, and there was a mix of answers. Some think that it definitely would—Abigail S. Bean even said that the book is what turned her vegetarian in junior high. Although, Jeff pointed out that if it were read in class, it's possible that teachers would focus more on the human suffering, which is definitely relevant, and less on the animal suffering. This leads to my second question in which I asked if Sinclair acknowledged the animal suffering. It is true that Sinclair wrote the book mainly to expose the abuses done to human beings, but as several of you pointed out, Sinclair wrote about the animal suffering, especially in chapter three, in which he wrote about the individuality of the hogs, and their ability to feel emotion and pain.

We'll have a lot more to talk about next week when we will discuss chapters 6 to 16. Have a great weekend!

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig

The Gist: Happy Tuesday everyone! I hope the week off has given you some time to read up on The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. I know this is a tougher read, but it's not too long of a book, and I find it quite interesting. The first chapters of the book introduce the main characters—two Lithuanian families who have recently immigrated to America in the early 20th century. The story focuses on Jurgis Rudkus' point of view, who is a younger man and gets a job almost instantly in a Chicago slaughterhouse due to his stature. The first chapter tells of the wedding, or veselija, between Jurgis and Ona Lukoszaite, which is a happy time, but also quite stressful due to the high cost of marriage and the fact that both of the families are impoverished. The second chapter jumps back in time before the marriage and talks about the voyage from Lithuania to Chicago of the two families, and their settling into an overcrowded boardinghouse. The third chapter takes the family on a tour of the stockyards, where they observe the slaughtering of pigs and cattle. Sinclair goes into a good amount of detail about the process and how tens of thousands of animals are killed per day. In the fourth and fifth chapters, the family buys a home, even though it will take them many years to actually pay it off. The chapters also describe Jurgis' new job at the slaughterhouse where his duties are to sweep the entrails of slaughtered cattle into trap doors. He is proud of the job, and is actually surprised when he learns that other workers hate theirs. He refuses to join a union, which is asking for a reduction in the pace of the work. At the end of chapter five, he observes downer cows and calf fetuses being killed secretly and packed with the rest of the meat, which does disturb him.

The Discussion: This is definitely a heavier book, and not always easy to read, especially the parts that describe the slaughter of animals. It was a very important book for its time, and is still pertinent today. Here are a couple of discussion questions for the first five chapters. I look forward to chatting with you!

1. Being a classic, this book seems very academic to me, since it depicts a part history in a very realistic way, but it's rarely included as required reading for students. Do you think there would be an increase in teenagers going vegetarian if this book were assigned reading?

2. Sinclair originally wrote this book to go against capitalism and to depict the abuse of humans. Do you think he was aware of or acknowledged the abuse of animals?

The Assignment: Please read chapters 6 to 16 for our discussion on September 13.

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig

Checking In

Hello VegNews Book Clubbers! I hope everyone has had a great week, and that you have been reading The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. We will be discussing the first five chapters next week, beginning on Tuesday, September 7. I am currently on chapter four, and I find it very engrossing so far. I look forward to the start of our discussion. Happy Labor Day weekend!

The Summary: Welcome VegNews Book Clubbers to the conclusion of our second month of the VN Book Club, in which we are discussing the final chapters of Skinny Bitch by Rory Freedman and Kim Barnouin. We will be taking a break next week, but will start right back up on September 7 where we will begin talking about the first five chapters of The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. I hope you guys are as excited as me to read this classic novel about the atrocities of the Chicago meatpacking industry in the early 20th century, and hope that the extra week gives you plenty of time to read.

Back to our discussion on Skinny Bitch! I first asked how you maintain a positive attitude, and the answers mainly focused on exercise, particularly yoga, but Changeintomule even mentioned being a part of CrossFit, which is awesome! Personally, I have started to ride my bike much more, specifically to work and back, which has really changed my mood for the better. I also feel much more focused during work, and even at home.

Finally, I asked about your thoughts on some controversy of the tone of the book, as well as if you think that "skinny" equals "healthy." This question definitely spurred different answers and opinions, both negative and positive. I think that it's important to have these types of discussions, because these are the issues that matter most. The book can be interpreted in a variety of ways depending on your outlook. If you consider yourself a feminist, there is some troubling language in the book that does not help the cause. But if you look at it in a casual matter, it could be read as a close friend giving it to you straight.

Please feel free to share anymore thoughts on Skinny Bitch in this post's comments section. It was a great month of sharing and I look forward to discussing The Jungle!

I would also like to announce the books we will be reading for the next three months of the VegNews Book Club, beginning with October:

October: Animal Camp by Kathy Stevens
November: My Year of Meats by Ruth L. Ozeki
December: Quantum Wellness by Kathy Freston

I'm very excited about this lineup, and I hope you are, too. Have a great weekend!

~VN Book Club Hostess Lyndsay Orwig